What is a Ithaca 37 worth?

Based on 13 completed auction sales, the Ithaca 37 has an average market value of $459. Prices range from $260 to $699.

Is now a good time to buy a Ithaca 37?

The Ithaca 37 market is currently stable. Check Gunny's live deals for current scored listings.

Markets/Ithaca/37

Ithaca 37

Name: Ithaca 37
Brand: Ithaca
Price: 458.5807692307693 USD

Confirmed (13 sales · all variants)Low ConfidenceUpdated Apr 15

$459market value↑ 0.0%— Heating Up

Full valuation View deals

GUNNY VALUATION

Basic plan required

Upgrade to Basic to unlock AI market analysis for any firearm. Upgrade now →

Market Average · 30-day

$459

30-Day Trend

0.0%

Stable vs 90-day avg

Price Range · 12mo

$260 – $699

12-month range

Sales Tracked

0

100% sell-through

Alert me under

Best Deal Live63

$325current bid

Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight, 16 Gauge

Loading variant data...

Price Trend14 sales

14 sales

Active Listings

View all

Market Momentum

0.0%

$459 · 30-day vs 90-day

Best Buys

ITHACA M37 12 GA Pump Shotgun Model 37 Ithica 870…$26043.3%

Ithaca Model 37 featherlight12-gauge Pump 26" w/ …$30533.5%

ITHACA GUN COMPANY 37 FEATHERLIGHT Shotgun PARTS -…$32728.8%

Overpaid

1950s Vintage Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight 20-Gaug…$705+53.7%

Ithaca 37 Featherlight 16ga 28” Barrel Full Choke.$699+52.4%

Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight 12ga Pump Vent Rib Vi…$630+37.4%

Recent Sales

14 results

Title	Sold Price	vs Market	Date	Bids
1950s Vintage Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight 20-Gauge 2 3/4in 26" Engraved	$705	+53.7%	Apr 17, 2026	18
Ithaca Model 37 featherlight12-gauge Pump 26" w/ Poly Choke 12ga	$305	-33.5%	Apr 14, 2026	1
ITHACA GUN COMPANY 37 FEATHERLIGHT Shotgun PARTS - USED	$327	-28.8%	Apr 13, 2026	15
Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight 12ga Pump Vent Rib Vintage No Reserve	$630	+37.4%	Apr 13, 2026	15
ITHACA M37 12 GA Pump Shotgun Model 37 Ithica 870 1100 500	$260	-43.3%	Apr 13, 2026	15
1971 Ithaca 37 Featherlight 20 Ga Blued OLD-SCHOOL AMERICAN MADE SHOTGUN	$425	-7.3%	Apr 13, 2026	21
1975 Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight Pump 12GA	$455	-0.8%	Apr 13, 2026	9
ITHACA GUN CO - MODEL 72 SADDLE GUN -.22LR- WEST GERMAN - EXCELLENT - USED!	$555	+21.0%	Apr 12, 2026	28
Ithaca Model 37 Featherlight 20ga. / 26" Used NO RESERVE	$396	-13.6%	Apr 12, 2026	18
Gorgeous Ithaca Gun Company Model 37 Featherlight 20GA Penny Bid NO RESERVE	$480	+4.7%	Apr 12, 2026	15

1–10 of 14

1 / 2

More Ithaca Models

1911$1,37050 1911A1$1,460 All Ithaca models →

Upcoming at Auction

RIAC

RIAC On Time Firearms Auction #5032

Closes Apr 26, 2026

View Catalog

Factory Engraved Ithaca Model 37 Sid Bell Edition Shotgun

Ducks Unlimited 40th Anniversary Ithaca Model 37 Shotgun